Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Davis

Rebecca Harding Davis promotes change within industrial capitalism. The harsh imagery she depicts using realism of her native hometown Wheeling, VA, is ostensibly worse for the lower working class than it is for the wealthy industrialists. She creates a notable division between the impoverished and the powerful through the interaction at the iron mill. The difference between the mill workers and Dr. May, Clarke, Kirby, and Mitchell was even evident to Hugh Wolfe who is one of the downtrodden characters suffering from Tuberculosis. 

Davis alludes to industrialism and greedy capitalists destroying the environment and the people's spirit. She even generalizes that most of these soulless upper-class individuals are passive christians who believe in and find solace with God, but aren't charitable nor benevolent because they don't think that pity is the proper way to reach the poor working class. These passive christians are metaphorically portrayed later on in the story before Hugh goes to prison, when he is in the upper-class church. The preacher fails to reach Hugh using language meant for cultured and well-educated church members.

All-in-all, Davis speaks out against the ignorant nature of greedy capitalists who fail to see all the damage they have done to the environment and the people who live in it because of their passive coexistence with the lower class, and failure to understand the needs, desires, and aspirations of the lower working class.

4 comments:

  1. Great post. You have a real good analysis of the story. The reality was that capitalists did have to coexist with the lower classes. Its amazing how blind they were to the needs of society. I hesitate to say it was ironic, but the fact so much change and prosperity was occurring it wasn't without a price!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, thought the story did the American factory worker justice. The were grossly mistreated during the industrial revolution and this story served and an excellent "look what you've done" message for the higher society who benefited from them greatly.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Carson, your comment is funny. Noah. Great post! I agree with you and your analysis of the story. Davis does do an excellent job at giving justice to the lower class immigrants in the factory. Great job.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey Noah,

    You did a really great job on your lead respondent. The points that you brought up helped me understand the story more. When I was ready the story my heart when out the the mills workers cause they were doing all this hard work and getting lousy pay. Good Job!

    ReplyDelete